Comparison

RecruiterDesk vs a spreadsheet

For a lot of recruiters, the most common tool is not software at all. It is a spreadsheet. Plenty of good recruiters run a whole desk on Excel or Google Sheets, and for a brand-new solo recruiter that is often the right call: it is free, flexible, and everyone already knows how to use it.

So this is an honest comparison, not a strawman. A spreadsheet is a capable starting point. The question is what it costs you once you are juggling several mandates, clients and candidates at once, and that is where a purpose-built workspace starts to pay for itself.

RecruiterDesk a spreadsheet
Cost Flat, published monthly price, every feature included Free, already on your machine
Pipeline and stages Real stages that move a candidate forward Status is just text; things silently slip
Fitment scoring JD becomes a weighted checklist automatically Hand-built and easy to skip
Follow-ups Reminders and an activity trail Lives in memory or scattered cells
Linked records One candidate, client and mandate, linked Copy-paste and drift across tabs
Submissions Branded reports in a click Built by hand each time
Candidate history Notice and joining details carried to the next mandate; past drop-outs shown Re-asked each time, or buried in an old tab
Data protection Built in, with export and delete Candidate data in an ad-hoc sheet, no controls

When a spreadsheet is enough

If you are just starting out, working one or two mandates, and you want zero cost and total flexibility, a single well-kept sheet is genuinely fine. Google Sheets even adds real-time collaboration and cloud access for free. Do not buy software to solve a problem you do not have yet.

Questions

Comparison questions

Is a spreadsheet good enough for recruiting?

For a brand-new recruiter with one or two mandates, often yes. A spreadsheet is free, flexible and familiar. It starts to cost you once you juggle several mandates and clients, because there is no real pipeline, no fitment scoring, no reminders, and no safe handling of candidate data.

Why move from Excel to recruitment software?

You move when the manual work of a spreadsheet, scoring candidates by feel, chasing follow-ups from memory, rebuilding submissions, and keeping candidate data organised and compliant, starts costing you more time and placements than the software costs. RecruiterDesk adds that structure for one flat monthly price.

How do I keep track of candidates who backed out before?

In a spreadsheet, it depends on someone remembering to type a note in the right tab. In RecruiterDesk, if a candidate withdrew, took another offer or a counter-offer, went unresponsive or lost interest on an earlier mandate, a Before chip shows wherever they are added again, with the role, client, round and date, read from the record itself. Details that belong to the person, such as notice, buyout and earliest joining date, are filled in on their next mandate, so you do not ask again.

Can I move my spreadsheet data into RecruiterDesk?

Yes, and in both directions. Import your candidate sheet as Excel or CSV by mapping its columns onto the talent fields, or drop their resumes in bulk. Add your clients by hand in a minute, and add mandates by hand or import a client's demand tracker into mandates in one go. Export everything to CSV at any time, so moving off a spreadsheet does not lock you in.

See it on your own desk.

Start free for 7 days, no card. The fastest way to compare is to add a real mandate and watch the fitment checklist build.

RecruiterDesk vs a spreadsheet, in a line

For a solo recruiter or a boutique agency that wants to start today at a flat, published price, RecruiterDesk is the focused choice. If you need what a spreadsheet is built for, its breadth is the reason to pick it.